I Swiped the Wrong One Review: A Charming Rom-Com!

June 30, 2026 Surya Komal 0 Comments Dustin Andrews, Emily Moore, Hollywood, Hollywood Movie Reviews, Hollywood Movies, I Swiped the Wrong One, Joe Fishel, Laura Irene Young, Nicholas Zarzeczny, Rachel Pfennigwerth

I Swiped the Wrong One is one of those simple, easygoing romantic comedies that doesn’t try to reinvent the genre or manufacture unnecessary conflict. Instead, it embraces a warm, mature, and comforting tone that makes for an effortlessly enjoyable watch. It’s the kind of film you can put on during a quiet afternoon, sit back, relax, and simply enjoy the company of its characters. There aren’t any over-the-top twists or melodramatic misunderstandings. Rather, the film finds its charm in everyday conversations, relatable situations, and people trying to navigate relationships at a later stage in life.

The story follows four adults whose lives have all taken different paths before eventually leading them to the unpredictable world of online dating. Amanda returns home to Pittsburgh after her political career comes crashing down, while Michael is still trying to move on from his divorce. Alongside them are Ashley and Matthew, who are also searching for companionship in a world dominated by dating apps and carefully curated online profiles. What begins as a familiar rom-com setup gradually becomes a story about second chances, maturity, and discovering human connection beyond the swipe culture that dominates modern relationships.

One of the biggest strengths of I Swiped the Wrong One is how grounded and mature it feels. Compared to writer Joe Fishel’s previous work, The Haunting of Prince Dom Pedro, this is a complete tonal shift, and one that I personally enjoyed much more. Rather than focusing on young love or exaggerated romantic situations, the film centers around people who have already experienced disappointments, heartbreaks, failed careers, and failed relationships. They’re no longer chasing fairy tales, they’re simply hoping to find someone who understands them. That perspective gives the film a refreshing sense of honesty that fits perfectly with its central themes of authenticity, reinvention after failure, and finding genuine connection instead of chasing perfection.

Because these characters are older and more experienced, the dialogue naturally reflects that stage of life. Their conversations carry wisdom, self-awareness, and even a bit of playful flirtation without ever feeling forced. They understand boundaries, expectations, and the realities of modern dating, and the screenplay allows those interactions to breathe. Instead of relying on over-the-top comedy, much of the humor comes from awkward encounters, honest conversations, and the everyday absurdities of dating apps. It creates a very comfortable atmosphere where the audience can simply enjoy spending time with these characters.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Laura Irene Young (@laurairene_young)

That said, I did wish the film had spent a little more time developing its second couple. While Amanda and Michael understandably receive the majority of the focus, Ashley and Matthew feel slightly underutilized despite being equally interesting characters. Their journey had the potential to add another emotional layer to the narrative, and a little more screen time could have made the ensemble feel even more balanced. Similarly, while the film succeeds because of its simplicity, there are moments where introducing a bit more dramatic tension or emotional nuance could have elevated certain scenes and given the story a little more variety.

The performances across the board are another highlight. Rachel Pfennigwerth delivers a very impressive performance as Amanda, portraying her with maturity, vulnerability, and quiet confidence. She’s immediately likeable, and it’s easy to invest in her journey as she tries to rebuild both her career and personal life. Dustin Andrews also does a solid job as Michael, bringing warmth and sincerity to a character who is cautiously trying to trust again after his divorce.

The supporting cast contributes nicely as well. Julia Silverman and Ron Lake share wonderful chemistry as Amanda’s parents, providing several genuinely funny moments while still feeling believable as a supportive family. Emily Moore and Nicholas Zarzeczny also perform well as the film’s second couple, making you wish their storyline had received a little more attention.

Technically, the film is equally pleasing. The cinematography by Steve Croner and Nicholas Zarzeczny gives the movie an inviting visual identity. Warm color palettes, comfortable framing, and an overall soft aesthetic perfectly complement the film’s cozy atmosphere. Harvey Davis’ background score is equally effective, gently supporting the emotions of each scene without overpowering them.

Overall, I Swiped the Wrong One is a charming and heartfelt rom-com that understands exactly what it wants to be. It isn’t trying to create artificial drama or grand cinematic moments. Instead, it tells a sincere story about adults finding connection, rediscovering themselves, and embracing life’s second chances. Its mature writing, warm performances, inviting visual style, and comforting atmosphere make it an easy film to enjoy. While a little more focus on the secondary romance and an extra layer of emotional drama could have made it even stronger, the film succeeds because of its honesty and simplicity. Sometimes, that’s all a good romantic comedy really needs. You can now watch ‘I Swiped the Wrong One’ for free on YouTube now!