Batman: The Long Halloween Part I – Movie Review

Batman: The Long Halloween Part I is one of the new DC animated movies I had been patiently waiting for a long time. I love this string of DC releases. On the heels of the Justice Society, DC uses one of the most memorable Batman storylines from the 90s to appeal to fans of all ages. In Batman: The Long Halloween, Gotham’s favourite son, Batman, is in his early detective days searching for a killer who strikes on various holidays.

Related: Best Anime Series on Netflix Right Now!

I like the animation style DC is using for these animated features. The film’s noir aesthetics are very true to the Batman we’re familiar with, and this is the classical Batman, the standard we’ve come to know. His story has always had classical noir roots. Especially when it leans into its detective tropes as it evokes nostalgia for a long-forgotten style.

Batman: The Long Halloween Part I also possesses a brilliant cast of voice actors who brought their characters to life. Jensen Ackles voices for the protagonist Bruce Wayne. Naya Rivera voices for Seline Kyle. Josh Duhamel voices Harvey Dent. Most notably for me, however, was the voice actor for the Joker, Troy Baker.

The last voice actor for the Joker, who I can remember being this exceptional, was Mark Hamill in Batman: The Animated Series. It was one of the matchless renditions of Batman and Gotham city characters, in my opinion. I was impressed at how closely Batman: The Long Halloween Part I was able to follow its source material while keeping things fresh, upbeat and exciting.

The story flows, and they did a fantastic job of interweaving various storylines and notable characters without being confusing or forced. They even manage to slip in some moral debates relevant to the time, such as Batman himself being the underlying cause of increased criminal activity.


The one area Batman: The Long Halloween Part I does lose points for me in, however, was its music and soundtrack. Great soundtracks can put movies over the top and increase their memorability. (For example, Batman: The Mystery of Batwoman).

It is a tiny criticism as I thoroughly enjoyed Batman: The Long Halloween Part I and await Part II. It’s an adult version of the Batman we grew up on, and it most definitely created for fans of the 90s animated series that are all grown up now. Rent the movie on Google Play here.

‘Batman: The Long Halloween Part I’ Rating – 4.5/5

Follow Jennifer (the Author) on Instagram – @islandgirlreview


Jennifer Arthur

View Comments

Recent Posts

Rooted Out – Chapter One Review: A Timely Intimate Drama!

Political disagreements are often uncomfortable to watch because they're rarely about politics alone. More often… Read More

18 hours ago

Demon Hunter: Time 2 Kill Review – Campy Horror Fun!

Some movies aim for realism, while others proudly embrace chaos, camp, and unapologetic fun. Demon… Read More

3 days ago

What Only Cicadas See Review: A Rewarding Slow-Burn Thriller!

With artificial intelligence becoming the centerpiece of countless films in recent years, it's easy to… Read More

4 days ago

The Sanctuary (2025) Review: Relevant & Compassionate!

Independent dramas often thrive not because of elaborate production values or grand cinematic spectacle, but… Read More

5 days ago

Local Area Network Review: Thoughtful Character-Driven Drama!

When I first read the logline for Local Area Network, I assumed I knew exactly… Read More

6 days ago

SAFILM 2026 Review: “Coconut Valley” – An Adventure with Heart!

There’s something inherently charming about films that embrace spontaneity. Rather than relying on polished setups… Read More

7 days ago

We use cookies, just to track visits to our website, we store no personal details.